Gun Buyback: Should You Participate?

gun 3603731 640

What would you do if you saw an advertisement offering you a gift worth $50 in return for one of your guns? Would you turn one, or several of them in? I ask, because there was a gun buyback in Memphis a few months ago where over 700 guns were reportedly turned in for a $50 gift. The gift came in one of several forms, to include sports tickets, gas and food gift cards.


700 guns were turned in without a single question asked. And the authorities have said that these firearms will never be available to civilians again. But, as with much of the liberal thinking that is out there, there are problems with this thought. First, and perhaps foremost, I can all but guarantee that any of the thugs with guns (of any race, color or creed) didn't turn in their guns. This means that I'd still need my own firearms to protect my family.

[instagram url= hidecaption=true width=625]

But, I guess it could happen. Maybe someone feels bad about killing that drug dealer so they want to turn their gun in. Which brings me to my next point…

Gun Buyback: Should You Participate?

The source article said that the turned in-firearms were taken with no questions asked. WTF? What if, by some off chance, that weapon was stolen and used to kill someone? Then there is no investigation to be had, because any criminals that did turn in their “unwanted guns” weren't asked any questions when they did so.

Finally, if someone turns in a stolen firearm, which will never again be made available for civilian use, what happens to the original gun owner who filed the stolen gun claim? Will that person be notified that his/her firearm was returned? Clearly, it will never make it back into his/her hands.

The Rock Island Armory TAC Ultra FS HC | Best 9mm Handguns For Women


The point is: These sort of things don't work to get crime off the streets because the bad guys aren't first in line to give their guns away.

In fact, the mayor of the city has said that nobody has even bothered to run the numbers to see if the crime rate was reduced the first few times a buyback was conducted. What does that tell you? It tells me that there hasn't been a noticeable decrease in crime, but they don't want to come out and say that. Ya know, cuz that would make him look like the tool he is. 

I think most of the time, the people who do turn in their guns are people who don't know anything about firearms to begin with. They are people who had a gun handed down to them. Or, someone who used to hunt and doesn't anymore.

However, there are likely some people—those gun owners who think like us—who have participated. I've heard some guys who turn in their broken and/or worthless guns for $100 gift cards who then use those cards to go and buy another working gun.

Or, some people wait outside of the buyback, and offer “real” money to these “civilians.” I would be inclined to think that anyone with at least half of a brain will take real money in greater quantities than a gift card in lower quantities.

So, again, I pose this question to you: Would you participate in a gun buyback?

How much would it take to get you involved, and at what stakes? I'll start by letting you know what I would do:

No. You can't have my guns, broken or otherwise, for any amount of money. Unless, of course, you want the bullets first. And, it should go without saying that they'd be traveling at speeds starting at 1,000 FPS, and going up from there depending on the firearm.

What would you do? Let us know in the comments.

If you like this post, check out some of the others listed below:

Boston's Buy Back Program

Our Response to the Pope Gun Rant


13 Responses to :
Gun Buyback: Should You Participate?

  1. CaptTurbo says:

    Hmm, I’d be the guy standing in front of the tables offering the idiots $60.00 for the good ones. lol

    1. Michelle says:

      Agreed CaptTurbo.

  2. padre says:

    If the ones that won’t to take my guns will give me theirs in trade an enough boot I might thank about it for about 1 sec I guess the only way I will turn loose of my guns will be death then they will go to my kids

  3. Old people says:

    No I would not for any reason. They are mine and I will leave them to my very capable sons when I die. I will never give up my rights of any kind for any reason. Where I live the Thugs all are armed and they murder people just because it seems. I my self have been threaten’d many times. I always tell them they made more then one gun boy. So just incase I was not clear. NO,, No and NO !!!!

  4. didactic says:

    Yes, only if the reward offered was far above the worth of the gun. Like maybe if I had a shoebox full of junkers that I had bought for $15 apiece, and they were offering $75 per turn-in! Or one I had that was inoperable and impractical to repair.
    Then I’d take the money and buy a few good ones, elsewhere. Keep the industry healthy!
    I also like going down the line, if allowed, and offering 25% more than the turn-in price, for the good ones. Who knows what I might find and take home?

  5. Matthew Unfried says:

    I did last year. They were giving $100 gift cards to my local grocery store and I had two old junkers I’d inherited that were broken and appraised for $15 and $40. I turned a nice profit on something essentially worthless! I would never give up any of my good guns in a million years for any reason though! C’mon, I live in Baltimore!

    1. guncarrier says:

      — Please reply above this line —
      Thank you for your email! We always appreciate it when our readers take the time to email us with their comments. If you have any further questions or issues we would be happy to assist you. Thank you and have a great day!

      Customer Service Advocate

  6. Concerning gun buy back 50 or 100 dollars gift cards I DON’T THINK SO! So little for MY FN-FNX 45 DA 15 RD with tax it just under $700 and also the ,12 mags to go with it NOT A CHANCE IN HELL ! Or any other hand gun I own. So instead of my 2 cents worth that’s my million dollars worth. !!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Enter for a chance to WIN an Over Under Double Barrel Shotgun when you sign up today for our exclusive email newsletter subscription.