The Advantages and Disadvantages of Off-Body Carry

Off-Body Carry Fanny Pack

There are both benefits and hazards to off-body carry. Using a fanny pack as a modern-day gun bag is comfortable and makes it easy to dress but also requires significant practice as it could lead you to become disarmed or even forget your gun behind.

As with anything, it is important to know the advantages and the disadvantages before adopting this technique as your own.

Off-Body Carry in Fanny Pack is Beneficial But Risky

Depending on who you talk to what articles you read, or what videos you see, carrying your gun any other way than on your hip is for losers. This discounts, of course, the half-dozen other ways you can carry concealed safely and effectively, including appendix carry, ankle, belly band, cross draw (an oldie, to be sure), small of your back, or shoulder rig.

The current theory is that you should be able to get your hand on your gun and get it out of your holster (two distinct moves) within three seconds of seeing an armed threat. I don’t disagree.

So, if I’m going to do an off-body carry, in my fanny pack (aka man bag, belly pack, belly bag, butt pack), I need to be just as fast getting it out of there as I do when I draw from my IWB or ankle holster.

Fanny Pack: The Modern Gun Bag

A few fine points about my approach to off-body carry: Your mileage may vary, especially if you don’t do it all because you think it’s not fast enough, too girly, or whatever reason you need not tell me.

I choose to use my little bag with one big zippered pocket (for my gun) and one little zippered pocket (for my spare mags or speedloaders), depending on my gun choice that day.

I don’t ever wear the bag around my waist; I sling it over my non-gun hand shoulder when I get out of my car and walk into the grocery store. When I’m in a restaurant or at the movies, I buckle it around my left thigh. I never leave it behind in a shopping cart or when I go to the bathroom.

Truth be told, I have left my gun bag in two restaurants over the past ten years. There are few worse feelings in the world than realizing that your firearm is back in your booth as you’re driving away.

Both times I raced back and it was still on the seat. Stupid is as stupid does, sir. That would have been an awkward conversation with the waitress, the hostess, or the cops if they had opened my bag. As such, I have created a number of important habits that make that dumb move impossible to occur again.

Advantages of Off-Body Carry

For me, the benefits to off-body carry via a gun bag are plenty.

Off-Body Carry is Comfortable

It’s just more comfortable than an IWB holster. Despite all the advancements, foam and felt pads, and other attempts at comfort, even the most strident IWB carrier must admit that the thing cuts into your belly, rubs your hip bone, stabs your side when you climb into your car and is a general pain in warm weather.

Off-Body Carry is Easy

It makes it easy to dress, especially on hot days. Sometimes, I just want to wear shorts, flip-flops, and a t-shirt to the store, and not look like I’m shooting a catalog page for 5.11 Tactical gear. I don’t need a shirt and a cover shirt. I don’t need to wear long pants to cover my ankle holster. I don’t have to sweat through my clothes.

Off-Body Carry Doesn't Print

Gun bags don’t print. At least they won’t outline your gun if you have the right-sized bag for the right-sized gun. If you try to shove your 1911 Colt into a bag that’s too small and the butt sticks out, that’s just dumb and inviting problems.

I’ll admit I wonder if people are smart enough to consider I might have a gun in my bag as I stroll past them. It’s the right size and shape for one, and although I’m not wearing it around my waist, I’m guessing some people know.

Then again, a lot of people are either sheep or are distracted by their own lives – or both – so perhaps my secret is still safe with me.

Disadvantages of Off-Body Carry

As with all things in life, there are tradeoffs. Gun bags have their distinct disadvantages as well.

Off-Body Carry Requires Practice

You must practice getting your gun out fast or you’re dead. Not being able to get to the right pocket and then fumbling with zippers is a recipe for disaster. I have practiced with an empty gun at home (using the same safety habits as if I was dry-firing) until I can get my gun out of the bag and on target quickly.

I’ve done the same at the range, moving from the bag strap over my shoulder, to my hand, to the zippered pocket, to the draw and fire, as quick as a bunny. Under the stress of really needing your gun to protect yourself, you must already have that muscle memory in place.

Off-Body Carry Could Lead You to Become Disarmed

You could get disarmed. We already know bad guys like to snatch women’s purses off their shoulders. We’ve seen these incidents in grocery stores and mall parking lots, as a two-man crew drives up to an unsuspecting woman, and the passenger either leans out the window and grabs her purse or jumps out and jumps back in again with it.

Some bad guys are smart enough to recognize someone carrying a fanny pack might have a gun inside it. As such, I’m extra vigilant out in public or near people. Anyone who tries to grab my bag is going to lose the tug of war and get counterpunched until he falls to the ground.

Off-Body Carry Lends Itself to Forgetfulness

You could leave it somewhere (or it could get into the wrong hands). We all get distracted by life, our kids, and the stress of the moment.

People leave their cell phones, coffee cups, sodas, lunches, purses, briefcases, and other important things on the roofs of their cars and then drive away. You cannot, must not, and will not leave your gun bag anywhere where you are not in complete, always-touching-it control.

Lord help you if you’re dumb enough to leave it near your kids, ever. You must focus on the proximity of your gun bag to your hand and your body the moment you choose to carry it that way.

Check out American Tactical FX45 1911 | Gun Carrier Handgun Review at

Follow us on FacebookInstagram, Twitter, and Pinterest!

Disclaimer: All content on this site is for informational purposes only. Please read our full disclaimer here.

Editor’s Note: This post was originally published on May 4, 2018, and has been updated for quality and relevancy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Enter for a chance to WIN an Over Under Double Barrel Shotgun when you sign up today for our exclusive email newsletter subscription.